• Home
  • ABOUT
  • WORK WITH ME
  • Paint Colors
  • Shop Our House
    • Guest Bedroom
    • Front Living Room
    • Living Room with Fireplace
    • Previous Second Living Room
    • Current Playroom
    • Prior Playroom
    • Dining Room
    • Laundry Room
    • Oliver’s Bedroom
    • Guest Bathroom
    • Covered Lanai
    • Patio
    • Master Bedroom
  • CONTACT
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest

Within the Grove

Join the list to receive occasional news and special updates!

Pros and Cons of Laminate, Vinyl, and Tile Flooring

July 3, 2017

If you’re wanting to replace your current floor with either laminate, vinyl, or tile, then this is the post for you. Ryan and I spent the past 4 weekends debating between the three. At one point we were convinced we wanted laminate. The next morning (I guess we needed a good night’s sleep) we decided on tile. After driving around looking at tile options we switched to vinyl. Then it started all over again. This is how it went for a good month. BUT we did discover a lot about the pros, cons, and installation process for each material.

We were very picky when trying to find the perfect flooring for our home. It’s eventually going to be installed in the kitchen, main living areas, and the bedrooms. It’s a big decision! We wanted the wood look, the perfect ash color, a slight color variation but not too much to where it looks like zebra stripes once it’s placed down, texture like wood grain, and of course waterproof. No big deal, right? Wrong. I’ll have another post soon about what we finally decided on, but today, it’s all about the pros, cons, and installation materials for each type of flooring. Here’s our takeaway on the three types of flooring: 

Laminate

Laminate flooring consists of layers of high density fiber boards. The bottom is backing that can help resist moisture while the top layer is the design covered with a wear layer to help protect the design. For example, a wood look.

Pros

1. A fairly easy installation process.
2. Has great durability when it comes to high traffic.
3. Can be textured to feel like and mimic real wood.
4. Some are made with a water resistant barrier. But you still need to remove the water/moisture within 24 hours.

Cons

1. Can be loud without the proper or enough underlayment.
2. Can easily warp when it comes in contact with moisture. They are not 100% waterproof.
3. Can’t be mopped because of moisture/water.

Materials for Installation

Laminate || Measuring Tape || Speed Square || Hammer || Spacers || Utility Knife || Jigsaw || Power Drill || Wood Chisel || Damp Proof Membrane || Hammer Block

Luxury Vinyl Planks

First let me say this. Vinyl has come a long way from even a couple years ago. Luxury vinyl planks are formed into 6 wide inch planks that have the texture and color of the material it is mimicking. In my case, wood. With an interlocking system, vinyl flooring consists of a solid vinyl core, a printed vinyl layer (the pattern), and the wear layer. The bottom of some are made of cork which help make it a floating floor.

Pro

1. Very easy installation. No glue, nails, or underlayment needed.
2. Durable and flexible
3. Can easily be cleaned by mopping.
4. Can purchase scratch resistant and 100% waterproof vinyl.
5. Cork bottom prevents mildew
6. Can be textured to feel like and mimic real wood.
7. Resistant to mold, mildew, and odors which makes it great to install pretty much anywhere.

Cons

1. Sharp objects can gauge it and leave marks.
2. Durability is fair to great depending on the quality you buy.
3. Can discolor if exposed to direct sunlight by using outside. Rubber bottoms can also wear away the color.

Materials for Installation

Vinyl Flooring || Rubber Mallet || Utility Knife || Measuring Tape || Speed Square || Damp Proof Membrane || Polyform Underlay || Spacers

Tile

Here in Florida, you’re going to see tile in most homes. Usually made of ceramic or porcelain, tile can also mimic the look of wood.

Pros

1. Easy to clean
2. Very durable
3. The tile is scratch and stain resistant
4. Can be slightly textured to feel like real wood.

Cons

1. Grout can quickly get dirty even with sealer. You have to scrub it clean 1-2 times per year. This can be a long process if you have a lot of tile.
2. The grout can actually stain.
3. Installation can be long and difficult.
4. Any brittle items (glass, home decor) that fall on it, will easily break.
5. Can chip but you can use a permanent marker to hide the chipped piece.

Materials for Installation

Tile || Tile Spacers || Trowel || Sponge || Thinset || Grout || T Square || Wet Saw || Measuring Tape || Grout Float || 5-Gallon Bucket || Chalk Box || Power Driver

COST 

As always, cost is an important factor when choosing flooring. Ryan and I found vinyl, laminate, and tile that were all in the same price range. With that said, you can purchase the main flooring for around the same price. It’s the materials you need to install the flooring that can drive up the cost. Which is why I included the materials in this post for each type of flooring. For example, tile needs grout and thinset. Laminate needs a damp proof membrane and underlayment.  Vinyl is the only flooring that doesn’t need anything to install but I highly recommend placing down a damp proof membrane first.

I hope this helps you make a decision for your home or at least give you an idea of what you want browse. I look forward to sharing with you our final decision and the transformation of our master bedroom. That’s the room we will be tackling first. Wish us luck! 

Let’s keep in touch!

We have a brand new community over on Facebook, House & Home, where we’ll be chatting, sharing, and helping one another when it comes to home decor and projects. Come join us! Check it out here.

Like on Facebook || Follow on Instagram || Follow on Pinterest

Image Sources:

4 || 6 || 8

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Home Inspiration, Home of the Rishels, Home Project, Our Home Improvements

« My Summer GIVEAWAY
Free Printable // Give Me the Lemons »

Comments

  1. Anthony Cooper says

    November 13, 2019 at 9:58 am

    I was researching this from a very long time and end up being here. You have explained the differences very neatly and nicely. Thanks for posting such an informative post. Now I can confidently go for laminate flooring.

    Reply
  2. Jaime says

    June 21, 2018 at 6:55 pm

    Article writing is also a fun, if you know
    afterward you can write otherwise it is complex to write.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Looking for something?

withinthegrove

A little garden magic just by adding some solar li A little garden magic just by adding some solar lights. Notice the starburst pattern they give off? My favorite part! These would also work great along a deck railing, the top of a wooden fence, or on the side of stairs. I added both solar lights you see here to my Amazon shop!
Round 2 (and final!) for the grass install in our Round 2 (and final!) for the grass install in our backyard. Dang, does it feel GOOD to finally say that! It has been a long time coming and a little sweat equity saved us so much by doing it ourselves. Next on the backyard to do list is turning it into a tropical oasis by planting the flower beds. Think huge birds of paradise! Time to start planning.
It has been 6 years since we moved into our home a It has been 6 years since we moved into our home and visualized the potential our backyard would one day have. The first few years were spent clearing out and claiming our property back . Two years ago we built our dream garden, last year we built the play area that feels more like a magical treehouse, and this year we added a pool (still pinching myself every day). We’re seeing our hard work over the years starting to come together as we approach the finish line of installing grass and landscaping that’s going to bring it all together. As I always say, stay tuned because you know I’m going to share it all with you! And a little reminder for you to keep going because home takes time.
The garden is cleaned up, prepped, and ready for t The garden is cleaned up, prepped, and ready for the summer crop. What started as a single garden box has transformed to this garden space over the past few years. Favorite thing about it: being tucked away in this cozy corner with the winding paths throughout it. One thing I would do differently: using pea gravel instead of the granite rocks we went with. These rocks hurt! Pea gravel is smooth enough to comfortably walk barefoot on.
The grass is in! Saying BUH BYE to the dirt around The grass is in! Saying BUH BYE to the dirt around the pool for the first time since December when we broke ground. We spent the past few weeks installing irrigation throughout our backyard and around the pool. Yesterday we finally had the sod delivered and within a few hours it got us one step closer to finishing our backyard oasis. We still have a long ways to go, but my goodness does it feel good to see this part done! And we can finally check off the final inspection for the pool build.
What does it cost to fill a 16,000 gallon pool wit What does it cost to fill a 16,000 gallon pool with a garden hose? Our total came to $229! Does this total surprise you? This of course can greatly vary depending on where you live and your situation. For us, we live in Florida and on county water. We only pay water fees and not sewage. The water company did not give us a discount. We filled the pool right at the start of our billing month so this is it! Have you filled up a pool before? I’d love for you to share your cost, pool size, and location if you feel comfortable doing so!
We have a 16,000 gallon pool and filled it up with We have a 16,000 gallon pool and filled it up with a single water hose. And we for sure had some questions! Answering them here:

• Why not use a water truck? We weren’t in a rush, it was the best way to end this project watching it fill up, and it would have been more expensive. 

• Why not use our local fire station? Our local fire department doesn’t do this and it isn’t very common that most do. We wouldn’t ask if they did. 

• Did our water company give us a discount? Nope. Most water companies will take off the sewage fee but we only pay for water and not sewage where we live. We did notify them so they wouldn’t turn our water off thinking it was a leak. 

• What is that on the end of your hose? We added a filter on the hose to help reduce iron, scale, any other heavy metals and containments to help give our pool a fresh start. 

• How long did it take? 51 hours 

I’ll be sharing the cost soon so make sure to add your guess in the comments!
Pizza nights are back! And one thing we’re addin Pizza nights are back! And one thing we’re adding since our screen enclosure is gone, are these Bitefighter LED String Lights by @tikibrandproducts . You’ve seen us use them in our playset area and now for our patio area. They give us the ambiance we need at night while helping to fight off the mosquitoes as a 2 in 1 solution. There’s no odor, no mess, and they will last all season long. Cheers to the summer nights ahead! #ad #TIKIbrand
Protecting outdoor furniture for the summer!

It’s time to give your outdoor furniture the best start for summer and to help it last long term. Here are some things you can do to protect your outdoor furniture as we enter the summer season:

1. If you have wood furniture, it’s time to seal it! I use Thompson’s Waterseal on all my outdoor wood furniture except for teak. This protects it from moisture, sunshine, and mold/mildew.

2. Easiest way to help keep cushions clean is by spot cleaning throughout the season. I use 30 Seconds Outdoor Cleaner for quick, fresh looking cushions. 

3. To really protect cushions, Shield H2O provides a water repellent treatment that repels moisture and spills, which in return helps prevent mold and mildew. 

4. Have teak furniture? Use a teak SEALER and not an oil. Teak oil is a short term solution and easily washes out with rain. Time to seal it to last long term! 

I have everything I used in my Amazon storefront under outdoor.
Load More... Follow on Instagram

Sign up here to have our fresh posts delivered to your inbox!

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Copyright © 2023 Within The Grove • Customized by Brave Creative Design · Log in

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclosures + Photo Usage
 

Loading Comments...